| JUROR | ACTOR | "IDENTITY" | ORDER HE DECIDES TO VOTE "NOT GUILTY" | REASONS/OTHER INFORMATION |
| 1 | Martin Balsam | |||
| 2 | John Fiedler | |||
| 3 | Lee J. Cobb | |||
| 4 | E.G. Marshall | |||
| 5 | Jack Klugman | |||
| 6 | Edward Binns | |||
| 7 | Jack Warden | |||
| 8 | Henry Fonda | |||
| 9 | Joseph Sweeney | |||
| 10 | Ed Begley | |||
| 11 | George Voskovec | |||
| 12 | Robert Webber |